\documentclass[12pt]{amsart} \usepackage{amssymb,latexsym} \usepackage{enumerate} \makeatletter \@namedef{subjclassname@2010}{% \textup{2010} Mathematics Subject Classification} \makeatother \newtheorem{theorem}{Theorem}[section] \newtheorem{cor}[theorem]{Corollary} \newtheorem{lemma}[theorem]{Lemma} \newtheorem{pro}[theorem]{Proposition} \newtheorem{mainthm}[theorem]{Main Theorem} \theoremstyle{definition} \newtheorem{definition}[theorem]{Definition} \newtheorem{remark}[theorem]{Remark} \newtheorem{exa}[theorem]{Example} \newtheorem*{xrem}{Remark} \numberwithin{equation}{section} \frenchspacing \textwidth=13.5cm \textheight=23cm \parindent=16pt \oddsidemargin=-0.5cm \evensidemargin=-0.5cm \topmargin=-0.5cm \begin{document} \baselineskip=17pt %\title[On elliptic curves arising from Heron triangles]{On elliptic curves arising from Heron triangles} \title[On elliptic curves via Heron triangles and Diophantine triples]{On elliptic curves via Heron triangles and Diophantine triples} \author[F. Izadi]{F. Izadi} \address{Department of pure Mathematics, Azarbaijan Shahid Madani University, Tabriz 53751-71379, Iran} \email{izadi@azaruniv.edu} \author[F. Khoshnam]{F. Khoshnam} %\address{MDepartment of pure Mathematics, Azarbaijan Shahid Madani University, Tabriz 53751-71379, Iran} \email{khoshnam@azaruniv.edu} \begin{abstract} In this article, we construct families of elliptic curves arising from the Heron triangles and Diophantine triples with the Mordell-Weil torsion subgroup of $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times \Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$. These families have ranks at least 2 and 3, respectively, and contain particular examples with rank equal to $7$. \end{abstract} \subjclass[2010]{Primary 14H52; Secondary 11G05, 14G05} \keywords{Diophantine triple, elliptic curve, family of elliptic curves, the Heron triangle, specialization, rank, torsion group} \maketitle \section{Introduction} Triangles with integral sides and area have been considered by Indian mathematician Brahmagupta (598-668 A.D.). In general, the sides and area are related by a formula first proved by Greek mathematician Heron of Alexandria (c. 10 A.D - c. 75 A.D.) as $$S=\sqrt{P(P-a)(P-b)(P-c)},$$ where $P=(a+b+c)/2$ is the semi perimeter. Triangles with rational sides and area are known as the Heron triangles (for more information and fundamental results on Heron triangles, see \cite{Fin,GM,Rus}). Goins and Maddox have studied Heron triangles by considering the elliptic curve $$E_{\tau}^{(n)}: y^2=x(x -n\tau)(x+n\tau^{-1})$$ as a generalization of the congruent number problem (see \cite{GM}). In the same paper, they also have found 4 curves of rank 3 with torsion subgroup $\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z\times\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z$. %D. J. Rusin in his paper \cite{Rus} has considered a set of triangles in the plane with rational sides %and a given area $S$, and shown there are infinitely many such triangles for each %possible area $S$. He also has shown that infinitely many such triangles may be %constructed from a given one, all sharing a side of the original triangle, unless %the original is equilateral. Campbell and Goins \cite{CG} by analyzing the elliptic curve $$E_t: y^2= x^3+(t^2+2)x^2+x$$ defined over the rational function field $\Bbb Q(t)$ described connections between the problem of finding Heron triangles with a given area possessing at least one side of a particular length and rational Diophantine quadruples and quintuples. They also have studied the relation between these problems and elliptic curves with torsion subgroup $\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z\times\Bbb Z/8\Bbb Z$, and found a new elliptic curve with this torsion having rank 3 and an infinite family of elliptic curves with torsion subgroup $\Bbb Z/2\Bbb Z\times \Bbb Z/8\Bbb Z$ and rank at least 1. Having constructed a family of Diophantine triples such that the correspondent elliptic curve over $\Bbb Q$ has torsion subgroup $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times \Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$ and rank 5, Aguirre et al. \cite{ADP} have obtained two examples of elliptic curves over $\Bbb Q$ with torsion subgroup $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times \Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$ and rank equal to 11. Dujella and Peral in a joint work \cite{DP} have created subfamilies of elliptic curves coming from the Heron triangles of ranks at least 3, 4, and 5 - as a matter of fact, the rank 3 family is exactly the same as this paper (but with different notation). We are not sure that this is an accident or restatement of our rank 3 family via some transformations of parameter as they cited a preprint of this paper as a main reference. We will discuss this connection in the desired section. They also have given examples of elliptic curves over $\Bbb Q$ with rank equal to 9 and 10. %In the sequel, we see that our approach differs from others. This paper is organized as follows. In Section 2, a family of elliptic curves arising from Heron triangles introduced by Fine \cite{Fin} is considered and shown that the family has torsion subgroup $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times \Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$, and rank at least 2, and a subfamily of rank~$\geq3$. In Theorem 2.6, a subfamily of $Y^2=(aX+1)(bX+1)(cX+1)$ of rank~$\geq2$ is given. %It will be seen although the subfamily has a feauture like Fine's curve, its structure does not come from Heron triangles. This is a generalization of Dujella's work done in \cite{Duj1}. Therein, Dujella extended the Diophantine triple $(a,b,c)=(k-1,k+1,4k)$ to a quadruple by studying $Y^2=(aX+1)(bX+1)(cX+1),$ and proved that this elliptic curve has generic rank 1 over $\Bbb Q$. In Section 3, some examples of elliptic curves with rank 7 are given. %All the calculations have been carried out with \verb"SAGE"~\cite{sage}. \section{Main results} Let $S$ be area of the triangle $(a,b,c)$, i.e., $S=\sqrt{P(P-a)(P-b)(P-c)},$ where $P=(a+b+c)/2$. This formula, due to Heron, ensures us to have an elliptic curve $v^2=u(u-a)(u-b)(u-c)$ with non torsion point $(u,v)=(P,S)$. %This curve is (birationally) equivalent to %$${\eta}^2=(1-a\zeta)(1-b\zeta)(1-c\zeta),$$ %with the corresponding point $(\zeta,\eta)=\left(P^{-1},SP^{-2}\right)$. %with the change of coordinates, $u=\zeta^{-1},$ $v=\zeta^{-2}\eta$. The curve therefore is birationally equivalent to $y^2=(x+ab)(x+bc)(x+ac),$ with corresponding (non torsion) point $(x,y)=\left(-abcP^{-1},abcSP^{-2}\right)$, and is equivalent to $Y^2=(aX+1)(bX+1)(cX+1),$ with corresponding point $(X,Y)=\left(-P^{-1},SP^{-2}\right)$. In the sequel, we are going to treat with special families coming from these two kinds of elliptic curves. Consider the elliptic curve $E_k: y^2=(x+a(k)b(k))(x+b(k)c(k))(x+a(k)c(k))$ associated to the Fine triple: \begin{equation}\label{2.1} \left\{ \begin{split} & a(k)=10k^2-8k+8,\\ & b(k)=k(k^2-4k+20),\\ & c(k)=(k+2)(k^2-4). \end{split} \right. \end{equation} arising from a Heron triangle which has rational area $4k(k^2-4)^2$ (see \cite{Fin}). (Note that multiplication of sides in \eqref{2.1} by $(2(k^2-4))^{-1}$ implies that the resulting triangle to have area $k$.) One can easily check that $E_k$ has three rational points of order two: $$\left\{ \begin{array}{l} T_1=(-k(10k^2-8k+8)(k^2-4k+20),0), \vspace{.2cm} \\ T_2=(-k(k+2)(k^2-4k+20)(k^2-4),0), \vspace{.2cm} \\ T_3=(-(k+2)(10k^2-8k+8)(k^2-4),0). \end{array} \right. $$ As the change of coordinates $(x,y)\rightarrow(x-a(k)b(k),y)$ does not affect the group structure of $E_k(\mathbb{Q})$, we may consider $E_k$ in the form $y^2=x^3+Ax^2+Bx$, in which \begin{equation}\label{2.2} \begin{array}{l} A=k^6-12k^5+116k^4-480k^3+304k^2-448k-64,\vspace{.2cm}\\ B=4k(5k^2-4k+4)(k^2-4k+20)(3k^2-12k-4)\\ \qquad \times (k^3-8k^2+4k-16). \end{array} \end{equation} The next proposition \cite[p. 38]{hus} is given to characterize the Mordell-Weil torsion subgroup of $E$ over $Q(k)$ in Theorem 2.2. \begin{pro} Let $E$ be an elliptic curve defined over a field $\Bbb K$ of characteristic different from zero by $$y^2=(x-\alpha)(x-\beta)(x-\gamma)=x^3+ax^2+bx+c,$$ where $\alpha,\beta,\gamma\in\Bbb K$. For $(x',y')\in E(\Bbb K)$ there exists $(x,y)\in E(\Bbb K)$ with $2(x,y)=(x',y')$ if and only if $x'-\alpha$, $x'-\beta$, and $x'-\gamma$ are squares. \end{pro} \begin{theorem} Let $a(k)$, $b(k)$ and $c(k)$ be defined as \eqref{2.1}, where $k$ is an arbitrary rational number different from 0, -2, and 2. Then the elliptic curve $$E:y^2=\left(x+a(k)b(k)\right)\left(x+b(k)c(k)\right)\left(x+a(k)c(k)\right)$$ defined over $Q(k)$ has torsion subgroup $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} The points $\mathcal{O}$ (the point at infinity), $T_1=(-a(k)b(k),0), T_2=(-b(k)c(k),0)$, and $T_3=(-a(k)c(k),0)$ form a subgroup of the torsion group $E(\Bbb{Q}(k))_{tors}$ isomorphic to $\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$. By Mazur's theorem \cite{Maz} it suffices to check that there exists no point $E(\Bbb{Q}(k))$ of order four, six or eight. If there exists a point $T$ on $E(\Bbb{Q}(k))$ such that $2T\in \{T_1,T_2,T_3\}$, then Proposition 2.1 implies that all of the expressions \begin{align*} -a(k)b(k)+a(k)b(k)&=0,\\ -a(k)b(k)+b(k)c(k)&= k(k^2-4k+20)(k^3-8k^2+4k-16),\\ -a(k)b(k)+a(k)c(k)&=4(5k^2-4k+4)(3k^2-12k-4), \end{align*} must be perfect squares. But, it is easily seen that for $k=1$ none of the above expressions are perfect squares. Similarly, if $2T=T_2$ and $2T=T_3,$ then all of the expressions \begin{align*} -b(k)c(k)+a(k)b(k)&=-k(k^2-4k+20)(k^3-8k^2+4k-16),\\ -b(k)c(k)+b(k)c(k)&= 0,\\ -b(k)c(k)+a(k)c(k)&=-(k^2-12k+4)(k-2)^2(k+2)^2, \end{align*} as well as \begin{align*} -a(k)c(k)+a(k)b(k)&=-4(5k^2-4k+4)(3k^2-12k-4),\\ -a(k)c(k)+b(k)c(k)&= (k^2-12k+4)(k-2)^2(k+2)^2,\\ -a(k)c(k)+a(k)c(k)&=0, \end{align*} must be perfect squares. But, it is easily seen that for $k=1$ none of the above expressions are perfect squares. This contradiction shows that $T\notin \{T_1,T_2,T_3\}.$ Thus, by \cite{Maz} it is to prove that there exists no point $T$ such that $3T\in \{T_1,T_2,T_3\}.$ If there exists a point $T=(x,y)$ on $E(\Bbb{Q}(k))$ such that $3T=T_1,T\neq T_1$, then from $2T=-T+T_1$, the equation \begin{equation}\label{2.3} x^4-6h_1(k)x^2-4h_1(k)h_2(k)x-3h_2(k)^2=0, \end{equation} is obtained in which \begin{align*} %h_1(k) &= a(k)c(k)+b(k)c(k)-2a(k)b(k)\\ h_1(k)&=-12k^5-480k^3+116k^4+304k^2-448k-64+k^6,\\ h_2(k)&=4k(5k^2-4k+4)(k^2-4k+20)(3k^2-12k-4)\\ &\qquad\times(k^3-8k^2+4k-16). \end{align*} It can be easily seen that for $k=1$, the equation \eqref{2.3}, namely $$x^4+3498x^2+195841360x-21157921200=0$$ has no rational solution. Similarly it can be checked that there does not exist any point $T$ on $E(\mathbb{Q}(k))$ such that $3T=T_2$, $T\neq T_2$, and $3T=T_3$, $T\neq T_3$. Therefore, $ E(\mathbb{Q}(k))_{tors}=\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}\times\Bbb{Z}/2\Bbb{Z}$. \end{proof} \begin{theorem} With the terminology in Theorem 2.2, rank~$E(\mathbb{Q}(k))\geq2$. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Evidently the non torsion points $$ \begin{array}{l} {\mathcal P}_1=(-a(k)b(k)c(k)P^{-1}(k),a(k)b(k)c(k)S(k)P(k)^{-2}),\vspace{.2cm}\\ {\mathcal P}_2=(0,a(k)b(k)c(k)), \end{array} $$ lie on $E(\mathbb{Q}(k))$ , where $P(k)$ and $S(k)$ are respectively the associated semi perimeter and area to ($a(k), b(k), c(k)$). For $k=1$, the elliptic curve $E(\mathbb{Q}(k))$ turns into $$E_1:y^2=x^3-\frac{73}{36}x^2-\frac{85}{4}x+\frac{7225}{144},$$ with $${\mathcal P}_1=\left(\frac{85}{18},\frac{85}{27}\right),\quad {\mathcal P}_2=\left(0,\frac{85}{12}\right).$$ The N\'{e}ron-Tate height matrix \cite[p. 230]{washh} associated to these points is of non vanishing determinant $\approx2.30842249514247$ (carried out with \verb"SAGE" \cite{sage}) showing that the points are linearly independent.Therefore the rank of $E$ over $\Bbb Q(k)$ is $\geq2$ , and hence, by the specialization theorem of Silverman \cite{sil}, the rank~$E_k(\Bbb Q)\geq2$ "for all but finitely many rational numbers $k.$ " \end{proof} \begin{pro} For each $2\leq r \leq 7,$ there exists some $k$ such that $E_k$ defined in Theorem 2.2 has torsion subgroup ${\Bbb{Z}}/{2\Bbb{Z}}\times{\Bbb{Z}}/{2\Bbb{Z}}$ and rank $r$. \end{pro} \begin{proof} The first part is readily obtained from Theorem 2.2. For the second part, it suffices to note that for the values of $k=$ 4, 7, 19, 11, $98/625$, and $88/31$, the corresponding ranks with using of Mwrank \cite{CER}, are 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7, respectively. \end{proof} Now, we are ready to show our main result: \begin{theorem} There exists a subfamily of $E_k$ of rank $\geq3$ over $\mathbb{Q}(m).$ \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Obviously the non torsion points $$\begin{array}{l} {\mathcal P}_1=(4(5k^2-4k+4)(k^2-4k+20), \vspace{.2cm}\\ \qquad\qquad\qquad 8(5k^2-4k+4)(k^2-4k+20)(k-2)^3),\vspace{.2cm}\\ {\mathcal P}_2=(2(5k^2-4k+4)k(k^2-4k+20),\vspace{.2cm}\\ \qquad\qquad\qquad 2k(k-2)(5k^2-4k+4)(k^2-4k+20)(k+2)^2), \end{array} $$ lie on the curve $E_k:y^2=x^3+Ax^2+Bx$. In order to find a subfamily of rank~$\geq3$, we proceed as following. Let $B_1=2k(3k^2-12k-4)(k^2-4k+20)$, and for some rational numbers $M,N,e$, ${\mathcal P}_3=(B_1M^2/e^2,B_1MN/e^3)$ be on $E_k$. This implies the quartic equation $B_1M^4+AM^2e^2+B_2e^4=N^2.$ Taking $M=e=1$, we get $(k-6)(k+2)^5=N^2,$ hence, $(k-6)(k+2)=z^2,$ where $z=N/(k+2)^2$. Using the rational solution $(k,z)=(6,0)$, the parametric solution is then $(k,z)=(2(3m^2+1)/(m^2-1), 8m/(m^2-1)),$ where $m\in \mathbb{Q}\setminus\{\pm 1\}$. Therefore, $N=2^9m^5/(m^2-1)^3$ and ${\mathcal P}_3$ turns into \begin{align*} {\mathcal P}_3&=(B_1,B_1N)\vspace{.2cm}\\ &=\bigg(\frac{2^{12}(3m^2+1)(m^4+4m^2+1)(m^4+1)}{(m^2-1)^5}, \vspace{.2cm}\\ &\qquad\qquad\qquad\frac{2^{21}(3m^2+1)(m^4+4m^2+1)(m^4+1)m^5}{(m^2-1)^8}\bigg). \end{align*} Thus $E_k$ turns into $E_m:y^2=x^3+Ax^2+Bx$ with $$ \begin{array}{l} \displaystyle A=\frac{2^{13}(m^{12}+14m^{10}-5m^8+4m^6+11m^4+6m^2+1)}{(m^2-1)^6},\vspace{.2cm}\\ \displaystyle B=-\frac{2^{24}(m^6-5m^4-3m^2-1)M_1M_3}{(-1+m^2)^{10}}, \end{array} $$ and three non torsion points $$ \begin{array}{l} \displaystyle{\mathcal P}_1=\left(\frac{2^{12}M_1}{(m^2-1)^4},\frac{2^{19}M_1(1+m^2)^3}{(m^2-1)^7}\right),\vspace{.2cm}\\ \displaystyle{\mathcal P}_2=\left(\frac{2^{12}(m^4+1)M_2}{(-1+m^2)^5},\frac{2^{20}(m^4+1)m^4(m^2+1)M_2}{(m^2-1)^8}\right),\vspace{.2cm}\\ \displaystyle{\mathcal P}_3=\left(\frac{2^{12}(m^4+1)M_3}{(m^2-1)^5},\frac{2^{21}(m^4+1)m^5M_3}{(m^2-1)^8}\right), \end{array} $$ where $$ \begin{array}{l} M_1=(m^4+1)(5m^4+4m^2+1),\vspace{.2cm}\\ M_2=(3m^2+1)(5m^4+4m^2+1),\vspace{.2cm}\\ M_3=(3m^2+1)(m^4+4m^2+1). \end{array} $$ Regarding the specialization theorem, since for $m=1/2$, the N\'{e}ron-Tate height matrix associated to these points has non vanishing determinant $\approx11.9727247292862$, then $E_m$ as a subfamily of $E_k$ is of rank~$\geq3$ over $\mathbb{Q}(m).$ \end{proof} {\bf Remark 1}. We are going to explain how the subfamily in [DP] comes from our subfamily as we mentioned in the introduction. To this end, first we divide $a(k)$, $b(k)$, and $c(k)$ by $8(k-2)$ and then compute $a(k)+b(k)-c(k)=(k+2)^2/(2k-4)$ and $c(k)/(a(k)+b(k)+c(k))=(k-2)/4.$ We do the same computations for Brahmagupta's triples $a=n(m^2+1$, $b=m(n^2+1$, and $(m+n)(mn-1)$ by letting $k=1$ to get $a+b-c=2(m+n)$, and $c/(a+b-c)=(mn-1)/2$. By equating the corresponding expressions one can get $m+n=(k+2)^2/(4k-8)$, and $mn=k/2$. Now the corresponding quadratic equation gives rise to $m=2k/(k-2)$, and $n=(k-2)/4$. By introducing a new variable $w$ satisfying the relation $mn=(w^2+3)/(w^2-1)$ as in [DP, section 2.3], one obtains by substituting the above values of $m$ and $n,$ $$k=2\times (3+w^2)/(1-w^2)=2 \times(3s^2+1)/(s^2-1),$$ where $s=1/w,$ which is exactly the parametric solution already given in the preprint as well as in the proof of Theorem 2.5 of the present paper. We say that (\cite{Duj2}) the Diophantine triple $(a,b,c)$ has the property $D(n)$, for any non zero integer $n$, whenever there exist rational $r,s,$ and $t$ such that $$ab+n=r^2,\qquad ac+n=s^2,\qquad bc+n=t^2.$$ \begin{theorem} There exists a subfamily of $C: Y^2=(aX+1)(bX+1)(cX+1)$ over $\mathbb{Q}$ with rank~$\geq2$. % which essentially does not come from Heron triangles. \end{theorem} \begin{proof} Consider the triple $(a,b,c)=(k-1,k+1,4k)$ with property $D(1)$. The curve $C_k:Y^2=((k-1)X+1)((k+1)X+1)(4kX+1), k\in\Bbb Q,$ has non torsion point ${\mathcal P}_1=(0,1).$ [The triple $(k-1,k+1,4k)$ has the property $D(1)$, but does not form any triangle (note $a(k)+b(k)20$, $SN(10000,E_k)>30$, and $SN(100000,E_k)>40$. Among these sieved $k$'s, it is considered the ones with high Selmer-rank. Then, rank computations are carried out with \verb"MWrank". This process shows that for $k=\frac{30}{259}$, $\frac{67}{93}$, $\frac{88}{31}$, $\frac{98}{337}$, $\frac{263}{666}$, $\frac{280}{919}$, $\frac{593}{150}$, $\frac{596}{19}$, $\frac{609}{76}$, $\frac{845}{33}$, rank~$E_k(\Bbb Q)=7$. \begin{thebibliography}{HD} \normalsize \baselineskip=17pt \bibitem[ADP]{ADP} J. Aguirre, A. Dujella, and J. C. Peral, \emph{On the rank of elliptic curves coming from rational Diophantine triples}, Rocky Mt. J. Math., 42 (2012), 1759-1776. \bibitem[CG]{CG} G. Campbell, E. H. Goins, \emph{Heron triangles, Diophantine problems and elliptic curves}, preprint. \bibitem[CE]{CER} J. Cremona, \emph{mwrank program}, available at\\ http://homepages.warwick.ac.uk/staff/J.E.Cremona/mwrank/index.html. \bibitem[Duj1]{Duj1} A. Dujella, \emph{A parametric family of elliptic curves}, Acta Arith., {\bf 94} (2000) 87-101. \bibitem[Duj2]{Duj2} A. Dujella, \emph{Diophantine $m$-tuples and elliptic curves}, J. Theor. Nombres Bordeaux {\bf 13} (2001) 111-124. \bibitem[DP]{DP} A. Dujella, J. C. Peral, \emph{Elliptic curves coming from Heron triangles}, Rocky Mt. J. Math., to appear. \bibitem[Fin]{Fin} N. J. Fine, \emph{On rational triangles}, Am. Mat. Mon. 7{\bf 83} (1976) 517-521. \bibitem[GM]{GM} E. H. Goins, D. Maddox, \emph{ Heron triangles via elliptic curves}, Rocky Mt. J. Math., 5({\bf 36}) (2006) 1511-1526. \bibitem[HU]{hus} D. Husemoller, \emph{Elliptic curves}, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1987. \bibitem[Maz]{Maz} B. Mazur, \emph{Rational isogenies of prime degree}, (with appendix by D. Goldfeld), Invent. Math. {\bf 44} (1978) 129-162. \bibitem[Rus]{Rus} D. J. Rusin, \emph{Rational triangles with equal area}, New York J. Math. {\bf 4} (1998) 1-15. \bibitem[SA]{sage} Sage software, \textit{Version 4.3.5}, http://sagemath.org. \bibitem[Sil]{sil} J. H. Silverman, \emph{Advanced topics in the arithmetic of elliptic curves}, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1994. \bibitem[Wash]{washh} L.C. Washington, \emph{Elliptic curves: number theory and cryptography}, Second edition, Taylor \& Francis Group, LLC, 2008. \end{thebibliography} \end{document}